New research by Joachim F. Hallmayer and colleagues released on 4 July 2011 raises questions about how strong a role genetic factors play in causing Autism. A large and careful twin study by Professor Hallmayer’s Stanford University team conducted with the support of the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) found that other factors known as the “shared environment” also influence susceptibility to Autism to a greater degree than previous research had indicated.
In genetics research, outcomes such as Autism can be caused by (a) genes, (b) shared environmental factors, (c) non-shared environmental factors, and (d) various interactions among these first three factors. (Technically, there is also “error,” a factor which is included to allow for some slippage is the relationships among these four.) Genes, of course, can be the same or different; in monozygotic or dizygotic twins they are all the same or 50% the same, respectively. The shared environment for monozygotic twins begins in the womb where they share the same placenta. After they are born, monozygotic twins are more likely to have more shared experiences (e.g., they are more likely to be dressed in matching outfits) than dizygotic twins, so they have a slightly greater shared environment than their dizygotic peer. Non-shared environments are the unique experiences people have; for twins, this factor is pretty minor, and it carries little power or weight. But, back to the chase….
In contrast, for example, to a famous study by A. Bailey and colleagues from 1995 that showed a very high heritability for Autism (92% of monozygotic twins were concordant for Autism but only 10% of dizygotic twins were concordant), the present study found that genetic heritability accounted for only 37% of the variance in Autism and shared environment factors accounted for 55% of Autism disorders. The findings hold whether Autism is diagnosed more strictly or more broadly; when Professor Hallmayer’s team examined Autism Spectrum Disorder cases rather than more narrowly defined cases, the percentages went up to 38% genetic and 58% shared environment contributions.
Continue reading ‘Is environment > genetics in cause of Autism?’

EBD Blog Comments